Select Page

Image: butcherbox.com | Post Images: Mostly via butcherbox.com

Butcher Box Reviews [2020] – Is it the best food subscription for you?

New? Start here. | This post contains affiliate links. That means that we receive a commission for purchases made on them (more info).

If you’re thinking about getting Butcher Box, you’ll need to take a look at Butcher Box reviews, especially this one.

In a sea of endless subscription boxes, finding the right one can be a bit of a challenge.

This rundown should give you all the information you need to make an informed decision on whether or not Butcher Box is the right food subscription service for you.

Contents

What is Butcher Box?

Butcher Box is a food subscription service that – much like all the others – delivers ready-to-cook meals directly to your door for a monthly fee.

This subscription specializes in shipping roughly 24 meals per month filled with 100% grass-fed beef, organic free-range chicken, and/or heritage bred pork in 5 different box plans (more info on those below.)

The Custom Box costs a little more than the other four, but offers more meat. Plus, while the cuts you receive in those boxes are selected by curators, the Custom Box gives you the ability to select your own cuts.

The prices and amount of meats in the plans above are all relative to Butcher Box’s “Classic Box” Each of them can be upgraded to a “Big Box” which doubles the amount of meat you receive at a little less than twice the price.

They also allow you to add other meats like bacon to whichever subscription you choose (for a little extra cash, of course.)

And if you’re a college student…

…Butcher Box has partnered with UniDays, which will save you $20 on every box, plus you get free bacon!

Finally, they ship all their meats with dry ice which ensures they stay cool while in transit. If the dry ice evaporates completely and your meat isn’t cold to the touch, contact customer service and they’ll replace and re-ship your order free of charge (but this isn’t a normal occurrence so don’t worry too much about it.)

Want to get this box for yourself or as a gift for someone?

Recent Butcher Box Items

Here are some of the cuts of meat you can expect to receive in your very own box. All meat amounts are according to the Custom Box choices and may be different in curated boxes.

Prices are the cost of the curated box, not the individual items.

ImageProduct NameBest FeaturePrice
Butcher Box - Whole ChickenWhole Chicken3.5-4.5 lbs. of organic chicken with no added hormones or antibiotics.$129
Butcher Box - Baby Back RibsBaby Back Ribs2-3 lbs. of pork baby back ribs, perfect for your next barbeque.$129
Butcher Box - Filet MignonFilet MignonTwo 6oz. Filets fill up one slot in your Custom box (you get 6 slots in the Classic Box size)$129
Butcher Box - Drum SticksDrum SticksThese drum sticks don’t mess around. Get three 1lb. drum sticks and cook ’em however you like. Don’t forget the wing sauce!$129
Butcher Box - Whole Pork TenderloinWhole Pork TenderloinA pound of whole pork tenderloin that’s super tender and ridiculously delicious.$129
Butcher Box - BurgersBurgersNo need to form the patties yourself! Six 1/3lb. burger patties fill one slot in your Custom Box.$129
Butcher Box - Boneless Skinless Chicken BreastsBoneless Skinless Chicken BreastsA classic choice for a quick dinner, three 1lb. breasts of free range chicken.$129
Butcher Box - Pork ChopsPork ChopsTough to cook, but absolutely delicious. One Custom Box slot nets you four 8oz. pork chops.$129
Butcher Box - Top SirloinTop SirloinFour 6oz. steaks from grass-fed cows that will make your mouth water with anticipation.$129
Butcher Box - Breakfast SausageBreakfast SausageMade by Butcher Box, you’ll get 1lb. of breakfast sausage packed with sage, oregano and sea salt.$129

Butcher Box Reviews

On the surface, this subscription is a great deal with plenty of sustainable-raised meats to choose from…

…and below the surface, it’s still a great food subscription service.

With a large number of customization options to choose from, you’re sure to get only the meats you want at a competitive price for a food subscription box.

Of course, for some people, it might be easier to simply go to the store and buy their meats, but for many of you, this box has plenty of reasons, it’s worth giving a try.

Things To Love About Butcher Box

Butcher Box has a lot to love. Check them out.

Here are 4 things to love about Butcher Box:

1. Responsibly Raised Meats, Sustainable Packaging

Do you know where your meat comes from? If you try Butcher Box, you will.

Butcher Box’s beef comes from Australian and US-raised Cows that are free to roam and feed on their natural diet, grass. They have access to shelter and are NEVER kept in feedlots. Their chickens are free-range instead of locked in cages, and aren’t pumped full of antibiotics and growth hormones. Plus, they’re certified non-GMO!

The Heritage Breed Pigs that Butcher Box’s pork comes from are fed an all vegetarian diet with no animal byproduct(the bacon you get from the grocery store probably has some of those though!). And if the way Butcher Box’s meats are prepared isn’t enough to get you interested, 95% of the packaging those meats come in can be placed in your recycling bin.

With humanely-raised animals and sustainable packaging, you can rest easy knowing that Butcher Box cares about the environment just as much as you might.

2. College Kids Save

Well if you’re a college student and are thinking about giving Butcher Box a try, here are some good news! You can save $20 on every box you get from Butcher Box AND get free bacon in every box.

The popular app made specifically for students, UniDays has partnered with Butcher Box to offer sweet deals on their food subscription service. Check it out if you’re a student and want to save some cash!

3. So Many Choices

Do you want Chicken? Beef? Pork? Salmon? Lamb? Or would you rather try all of them?…

… well with Butcher Box’s almost unlimited customization options, you can get whatever meats you want! Here’s a quick breakdown of each of their boxes:

The All Beef Box – 8-10 lbs. @ $129/month

The Beef & Chicken Box – 8.5-11 lbs. @ $129/month

The Beef & Pork Box – 8-11 lbs. @ $129/month

The Mixed Box – 8.5-11 lbs. @ $129/month (beef, pork and chicken)

The Custom Box – 9-14 lbs. @ $149/month (this one ships 30 meals instead of 24)

You can double the amount of meats in any of these boxes by upgrading the standard size (above) to The Big Box option for a little less than double the price of the standard boxes.

And if you STILL can’t get enough meat, Butcher Box allows you to add on as many extra cuts as you like for a little extra cash. Be careful with add-ons though… They renew each month unless you remove them from your box using the website.

different meats + add ons

Butcher Box Reviews: Things We Don’t Love about Butcher Box

Nothing’s perfect… Luckily, Butcher Box’s downfalls aren’t really that bad.

1. Promo Codes

The only time Butcher Box allows you to use a promo code is with your first order.

This is common with most subscription box services, but it’s still a bummer there aren’t more chances for more codes…

2. The Price

Meat ain’t cheap! And if you’re on a tight budget, you’re probably not going to be able to spend $129 worth of quality meat every month.

Pros vs Cons of Butcher Box

Below you’ll find an easy-to-read and more consolidated list of the pros and cons of Butcher Box.

Pros

  • Quality, sustainable-raised meats delivered directly to your door each month for a reasonable price.
  • Multiple subscription choices that allow you to receive ONLY the meats you love.
  • Receive 24 meals a month in the Classic Box or 48 meals a month in the Big Box, averaging $6 per meal.
  • Monthly specials allow you to add a completely new meat to your box each month. At the time of this writing, it’s Alaskan Sockeye Salmon.
  • Want extra meats? Add-ons are available.
  • No signature required upon delivery.
  • Free Shipping!
  • Choose which meats you want to receive each month in the Custom Box or have them curated by experts in any of the other boxes.
  • Each box is shipped in an eco-friendly package with dry ice which keeps your meats cool and fresh.
  • Monthly recipes available on the website to help you elevate your dinner game.
  • Receive free meat and cash savings on your next box when you refer a friend.
  • Extra savings for college students who have a UniDays account.

Cons

  • Can be a little pricey for people on a tight budget.
  • Promo codes are only available to use at the time of sign-up. You cannot apply them to future orders.

Butcher Box Price

The table below breaks down each of Butcher Box’s subscription plans, the amount of meat you’ll receive with each, the number of meals it’ll make, and the price per month for each box.

You can double the amount of meat you’ll receive in any of the boxes at a little less than twice the price by choosing the Big Box option instead of the standard size while signing up.

ImageSubscription PlanLbs. of MeatPrice
The All Beef Box (24 meals)8-10$129
The Beef & Chicken Box (24 meals)8.5-11$129
The Beef & Pork Box (24 meals)8-11$129
The Mixed Box (24 meals)8.5-11$129
The Custom Box (30 meals)9-14$149
The Big Box (Option for all boxes)Twice as manyDiscounted

Butcher Box Shipping Breakdown

Butcher Box ships to all 48 contiguous States, but not Alaska, Hawaii, or Canada.

Don’t forget, shipping is always free!

Is Butcher Box worth it?

At the end of the day, Butcher Box is a lot of meat for a great price (as long as you can afford spending that much all at once.)

And with all the customization options, it’s definitely one of our favorite meat subscription boxes out there right now.

Want to get this box for yourself or as a gift for someone?

Butcher Box Promo Code

Butcher box is currently offering free 2lbs of Wild Alaskan Sockeye Salmon, with your first Box. That’s not all, Shipping is Free! Click here to get your FREE Salmon!

How to Join Butcher Box

Are you thinking this is your type of food subscription service? Listed down below the easy steps to get this awesome monthly box.

Here is how to join Butcher Box:

1. Enter Your Email & Zip Code

Once you click “Choose Your Plan” or “Order Now”, this is the first bit of information you have to enter.

2. Select Your Box

Choose between the all beef, beef & chicken, beef & pork, the mixed box, and the custom box.

3. Select Your Size

The Classic Box is great for one person. The Big Box is meant for families (and large freezers)

4. Select Your Meat OR Select Your Add-Ons

If you choose the custom box, you’re able to select which cuts of meat you’d like (you can select add-ons as well). If you chose one of the other boxes, you can choose (or not) to add on some extra meats like salmon or bacon.

5. Proceed to Checkout

You know what to do here. Enter your billing and shipping information

6. Be Patient!

Your first box will ship in about a week after you place your order.

More Great Subscription Boxes

Still not sure if Butcher Box is right for you? Check out these other great subscription boxes.

  1. For those who love to snack, Universal Yums ships snacks from every corner of the globe.
  2. If you love all things Japanese, Wowbox ships only the best snacks straight from Japan.
  3. When you can’t get enough heat, Fuego Box has all the best hot sauces you’ve been dying to try.

In Conclusion

So there you have it, Butcher Box reviews, an in-depth look to help you decide whether it’s the right food subscription box for you.

Have you tried this subscription box? Send a comment about what you think.

Price

$129 @ butcherbox.com

Number of Meals Per Box

24 or 48

Customizeable Boxes?

Yes! With the Custom Box option

Free Shipping?

Absolutely

About The Author

Brian is the ultimate foodie, expert chef, and barbecue master. He grew up watching his dad work in the kitchen of a restaurant that their family previously owned. Out of this, he has a deep love for the food, wine, beer, spirits… and all things that taste good and bring people together.

Share
More
Tweet
Pin
Skip to content