Select Page

Firstleaf Wine Club Reviews – Is the price worth it?

New? Start here. | This post contains affiliate links (what is this?)

If you’re looking for great wine of the month club, make sure you read our Firstleaf Wine Club reviews before joining.

In this Firstleaf review, I’ll explain everything you need to know before you part with your hard-earned cash. I’ll tell you everything I love most about the service, all its drawbacks, and how shipping and pricing work.

Contents

What is Firstleaf?

firstleaf wine club reviews - what
Firstleaf Wine Club offers customized wine selections at a great value delivered right to your door.

Their team of wine experts and winemakers travel the world looking for great tasting wines. Once they find a wine they love, they buy directly from vineyards, allowing them to cut out the middleman and pass the savings directly to you. You’ll pay roughly $13 per bottle for wines that often retail for upwards of $20.

Your membership begins with a 3-question quiz to determine your basic taste preferences. The first question asks if you prefer reds or whites, the second asks about domestic or imported wines, and the third asks how many bottles of wine you typically drink in a month.

This might not seem like a lot for Firstleaf to build on, but that’s just the beginning of your customization.

Once you’ve created your account and specified your preferences, Firstleaf will send you an introductory box with 3 bottles of wine for you to taste and rate. Based on your ratings, Firstleaf will send your next box with 6 bottles chosen specifically for you from their large collection of award-winning wines and hidden gems.

As you rate your shipments, Firstleaf will continue to improve their selections to find wines that you love. In fact, Firstleaf is so confident that you’ll be happy with your wine, they offer a 100% satisfaction guarantee. If a shipment doesn’t suit your palate, they’ll either credit your account for the next shipment or give you a complete refund.

Firstleaf Wine Club wants to make buying great wine simple. With their customizable memberships, award-winning wines, and great value, I’d say they’ve reached their goal.

Want to get this box for yourself or as a gift for someone?

Recent Firstleaf Boxes/Items

firstleaf wine club reviews - items
Because each Firstleaf box is customized to the subscriber’s preference, your box will probably look different than mine. Still, this box is a great example of the range of delicious wines you can expect from your subscription.

Although I usually prefer reds, I decided to see if Firstleaf could find me some whites I’d enjoy and specified that I wanted a mix. I also specified that I wanted a mix of domestic and imported wines, so this Firstleaf Wine Club review could be as informative as possible.

In the price column in the table below you can see how much each bottle would cost you from the store. Keep in mind that with Firstleaf you’ll only pay $13 per bottle, giving you 40-50% off each wine.

ImageProduct NameBest FeaturePrice
firstleaf wine club reviews - scissor kickScissor Kick 2017 Cabernet SauvignonThis wine has flavors of red fruits, dark chocolate, eucalyptus, and tobacco.$22
firstleaf wine club reviews - rapheRaphe 2017 Sauvignon BlancFresh fruit and bright flavors won this wine a silver medal at the 2018 Harvest Challenge.$21
firstleaf wine club reviews - daring escapeDaring Escape 2016 RedThis wine is packed with complex fruit and spice notes that continue to reveal themselves with each glass.$22
firstleaf wine club reviews - gilded letterGilded Letter 2017 ZinfandelThis full-bodied Zinfandel has won gold medals from multiple wine competitions.$24
firstleaf wine club reviews - cassiday blareCassiday Blare 2015 RedA much less intense wine than the Daring Escape, the red fruit flavors in this wine are fresh and delicate.$25
firstleaf wine club reviews - idlewrightIdlewright 2017 ChardonnayCitrus, melon, spice, and oak flavors won this wine the Best Australian Wine award from USA Wine Ratings.$24

Firstleaf Wine Club Reviews

firstleaf wine club reviews - review
Now that you know the basics, it’s time to dive into the details with this Firstleaf Wine Club review.

In the next few sections, I’ll give you everything you need to know to decide if this is the right wine club for you. I’ll tell you what I liked most and least, and give you a list of pros and cons that you can use to compare Firstleaf with other wine of the month clubs.

Why We Love Firstleaf: 3 Reasons

firstleaf wine club reviews - love
In the process of making finding great wine simple, Firstleaf does a lot of great things. These are the three things I love most about this wine club.

Here are 3 reasons why we love Firstleaf:

1. Intro Box

firstleaf wine club reviews - reason 1
Although lots of services offer customized wine selections, not many give you the chance to test the service before fully committing.

With Firstleaf’s 3-bottle intro box, you can actually taste their wine before paying full price for a monthly subscription. For just $15 plus $4.95 shipping and handling, you can take Firstleaf for a test drive handing over the big bucks.

2. Satisfaction Guarantee

firstleaf wine club reviews - reason 2.1
It’s strange to love an aspect of a service that I’m likely to never use, but Firstleaf’s money back guarantee gives me a lot of confidence in my subscription. It’s good to know that if their selections don’t match my tastes I can get my money back, no muss no fuss.

3. Feedback to Winemakers

firstleaf wine club reviews - reason 3.1
Every customized subscription incorporates your feedback into their selections, but as far as I know, Firstleaf is the only service that passes your feedback along to winemakers.

By consistently rating your wine selections, you can actually make an impact on the wine industry by letting them know what you like and what you don’t. Just promise you’ll get drunk on wine, not on power.

Things We Don’t Love about Firstleaf

firstleaf wine club reviews - drawback
Even though there were several things I loved about Firstleaf, no subscription service is perfect. There was really only big issue I had with Firstleaf, a drawback that makes me think twice about being a subscriber.

Here’s 1 thing we don’t love about Firstleaf:

Nichelessness

firstleaf wine club reviews - nichelessness
The first words on Firstleaf’s homepage proudly proclaim “The Only Wine Club Tailored to You.”

But that’s just not the case. Customizable wine subscriptions are a dime a dozen, but each offers something that the others don’t… except for Firstleaf. Some focus on rare wines, some on wines with remarkable origins, and some make their own wines.

Firstleaf does make buying great wine easy, but so do half a hundred other companies that offer a unique approach to wine curation.

Pros vs Cons of Firstleaf

firstleaf wine club reviews - proscons
With so many wine of the month clubs to choose from, selecting the right one for you can be a daunting task. Use these pros and cons to compare Firstleaf with other wine clubs and make the choice that’s best for you.

Pros

  • Award Winning Wines – many of Firstleaf’s selections are heavily decorated with awards from various tasting organizations.
  • Personalized Selections – as you rate your wines Firstleaf learns what you like and keeps the good stuff coming.
  • Frequency Options – Choose to receive your wine every 1, 2, or 3 months.

Cons

  • Rating System – although the ability to rate your wines is a great feature, Firstleaf’s thumbs up/thumbs down rating system doesn’t allow you to give detailed feedback.

Firstleaf Wine Club Reviews Price

firstleaf wine club reviews - price
Firstleaf only offers one subscription option, but you can control the amount you spend by selecting the delivery frequency that fits your budget.

After your introductory box (3 bottles for $15 + $4.95 shipping) each full-sized shipment is the same price.

ImageSubscription PlanPrice
firstleaf wine club reviews - price table6 Bottles$79.95

Firstleaf Shipping Breakdown

firstleaf wine club reviews - shipping
Since Firstleaf is a wine of the month club, shipping is totally dependent on your local alcohol laws. You should be able to find that information on your city or county website.

Assuming it’s legal, Firstleaf ships everywhere in the continental US for a flat rate of $9.95 per box. Someone 21 or over must be present to sign for the package, so we recommend shipping to your work address to be sure you can receive the package.

Is Firstleaf worth it?

firstleaf wine club reviews - worthit
Firstleaf Wine Club is definitely worth the price. With retail values almost double the price subscribers pay for each bottle, the value of this customized subscription service is impossible to deny.

As I mentioned above, other subscription services have more specific niches, but if you’re just looking for good wine at a great price, Firstleaf is the club for you.

Want to get this box for yourself or as a gift for someone?

More Great Wine Of The Month Club Reviews

Looking for more great wine of the month clubs? Check out these reviews to find the subscription that works best for you.

  1. Find out everything you need to know about the original Wine of the Month Club here in our Mantelligence site.
  2. See how we feel about Winc’s original blends and customization in this Winc review.
  3. Get the scoop on one of the fastest growing clubs with our Vinesse reviews.
  4. Our Plonk Wine Club reviews fill you in on the hidden gems of this service.
  5. We rate the wines from small vineyards curated by Vinebox in our Vinebox review.

In Conclusion

Hopefully this Firstleaf Wine Club reviews gave you all the information you need to decide if this is the right wine of the month club for you.

If you found this Firstleaf Wine Club reviews helpful, share it with your wine-loving friends and spread the good news.

Want to get this box for yourself or as a gift for someone?

Subscribe

Price

$80 @ firstleaf.club

Number of Bottles

6

Subscription Options

Monthly, 2 month, 3 month

Shipping

$9.95

About The Author

Share
Tweet
Pin