Select Page

Image: | Post Images: Mostly via

Cheryl’s Cookies Review (2020) – Is this club worth it?

New? Start here. | This post contains affiliate links. That means that we receive a commission for purchases made on them (more info).

Bringing the best of Midwest baking traditions to the whole world, Cheryl’s Cookies was founded on the idea that the world deserved a better cookie. By crafting her cookies with natural ingredients and handmade care, Cheryl’s has become a go-to favorite for the sweeter side of food subscription boxes.

Whether you’re looking for a thoughtful gift for a friend or want to keep all of these delicious baked goods for yourself, they have an amazing monthly subscription for you. In this article, you’ll learn everything you need to know to make an informed decision about whether a subscription to one of Cheryl’s monthly boxes is right for you. Read on to find out more!


What is Cheryl’s Cookies?

More than 30 years ago, Cheryl set out to make the best darned cookies the world has ever had — or at least as close as she could get to it! Focusing on natural ingredients and handmade processes, this Ohio based business has become a favorite of sweets lovers everywhere.

How exactly has this small-town Midwestern girl found such success with her cookies? Many attribute it to her renowned buttercream frosting. If you’ve never had it before, buttercream frosting is made from just four ingredients: butter, vanilla, evaporated milk, and powdered sugar. People across the country agree that this is what has kept them coming back for more from Cheryl’s!

Due to the success of her buttercream-frosted cookies, Cheryl’s has also been able to branch out into other baked goods. From brownies to cakes and seasonal treats, they have something for everyone.

Want to get this box for yourself or as a gift for someone?

Recent Cheryl’s Cookies Boxes/items

Take a look at these six scrumptious subscription box options from Cheryl’s.

ImageProduct NameBest FeaturePrice

Cookies, Candy, and BrowniesBest variety$15-40

Gourmet CookiesNew styles each month$13-15

Gourmet BrowniesNew styles each month$20-22

Gluten FreeGreat for food allergies$24

Sugar FreeGreat for dieters$18

Buttercream Frosted Cutout CookiesTried and true — a longtime customer favorite$15-22

Cheryl’s Cookies Review

If you’re ready to dig into everything that a subscription to these delectable baked goods has to offer, you’ve come to the right place! This Cheryl’s Cookies review will cover everything there is to love, as well as just a couple things that aren’t quite so lovable. After a pros and cons list, you’ll learn exactly how much each subscription costs before getting a final verdict on the box.

Ready to find out whether it lives up to the hype? Then let’s get started!

Things To Love About Cheryl’s Cookies 5 of reasons

There’s no doubt about it, Cheryl’s Cookies clubs have a lot to love!

Check out these five reasons people rave about Cheryl’s:

1. Lots of options for different baked goods

With almost a dozen different clubs to subscribe to, there’s a perfect baked good for everyone.

2. Subscriptions suitable for dietary restrictions

Sugar Free and Gluten Free boxes open up subscription options to people who wouldn’t normally be able to eat baked goods.

3. Big discounts on longer subscriptions

The more months you sign up for, the less you’ll end up paying each month!

4. Fits almost any budget

With monthly plans starting at just $15, this is a luxury that just about anyone can afford.

5. No preservatives used

Each of the baked goods from Cheryl’s is truly fresh and has a handmade taste. You won’t find anything like these on grocery store shelves!

Things Not To Love about Cheryl’s Cookies: 2 of reasons

There are just two things that might be a little bit inconvenient about Cheryl’s:

1. Shipping isn’t free

In the world of food subscription boxes, shipping is almost always included in the price. For Cheryl’s, be sure to budget for the total cost when you’re looking at prices.

3. Needs to be eaten or frozen quickly after receiving

Cheryl’s amazingly fresh cookies, brownies, and cakes don’t use any preservatives (yum!), but this also means that they won’t stay at peak flavor forever. As soon as they arrive at your door, be sure to eat them right away — or freeze them for later.

Pros vs Cons of Cheryl’s Cookies

Here’s a breakdown of the attributes of a subscription:


  • Huge variety of baked goods subscriptions
  • Very accommodating of dietary restrictions
  • Big discounts on longer subscriptions
  • Options available for almost any budget
  • Only fresh ingredients; no preservatives


  • Does not have the free shipping of many other food subscriptions
  • All fresh ingredients means the baked goods won’t last forever once they arrive at your door

Cheryl’s Cookies Shipping Breakdown

Shipping with UPS, USPS, and FedEx, Cheryl’s offers multiple options for how quickly to have your cookies delivered. Because their baked goods are made fresh to order, they recommend using expedited shipping for orders west of the Mississippi River, as well as northeastern states and Florida.

If you’re looking to send it as a gift, there is an option available to have the package delivered on an exact day. Just change your shipping preferences at checkout, and include the date that you want it delivered.

Cheryl’s Cookies Price

How much does it cost? Take a look at their top four subscription plans here:


ImageSubscription PlanPrice

Buttercream Frosted Cut-out Cookie of the Month Pay-as-you-go Club – 24 cookies$20/month

Gourmet Cookie of the Month Pay-as-you-go Club$13/month

Enjoy Fall Cookie and Brownie Gift Tin$25/month

Gourmet Brownie of the Month Pay-as-you-go Club$20/month

Is Cheryl’s Cookies worth it?

For anyone who loves fresh-baked cookies, cakes, and brownies but doesn’t always have the time to make them at home, Cheryl’s Cookies is definitely worth subscribing to. If you’re thinking of getting a gift for someone that will keep on giving for months to come, Cheryl’s makes an excellent choice for anyone on your list with a sweet tooth!

Want to get this box for yourself or as a gift for someone?

Cheryl’s Cookies Coupon or Promo Code

There is no available coupon or discount.

How to Join Cheryl’s Cookies

Are you ready to join Cheryl’s Cookies clubs? Just follow these 5 simple steps.

Here is how to join Cheryl’s Cookies:

1. Go to Cheryl’s Cookies Clubs page

That’s right here, for your convenience.

2. Choose from their incredible selection of monthly clubs

Cookies? Brownies? Sugar free or gluten free? There are options for any sort of baked good you might want to have delivered. Add whichever ones excite you the most to your cart.

3. Check out with your cart

Go to your cart (it’s in the upper right hand corner of your screen), and make sure you’ve selected the right club.

4. Follow the onscreen prompts for shipping and billing information

Cheryl’s website will take you through everything you need to set up an account with them and have your cookies delivered. You’ll have options here to choose how quickly you want your fresh-baked cookies shipped to you.

5. Wait patiently for your cookie delivery

Be sure to bring your cookies indoors as soon as you can, and freeze any of them that you won’t be eating within a few days.

More Great Food Subscription Boxes reviews

While it might be tempting to subsist entirely on baked goods, there are plenty of other amazing food subscription boxes. Check out these crowd favorites, too:

  1. This Munchpak review will tell you everything you need to know about everybody’s favorite snack food subscription.
  2. Are sweets more your style? These Candy Club reviews have got you covered.
  3. If meat is more your thing, the Carnivore Club review is just for you.

In Conclusion

Thank you for reading this comprehensive Cheryl’s Cookies review! If you haven’t found everything you need, please be sure to check out all these other food subscription boxes to narrow it down to just what you’re looking for.

Want to get this box for yourself or as a gift for someone?

About The Author

Brian A

Brian is the ultimate foodie, expert chef, and barbecue master. He grew up watching his dad work in the kitchen of a restaurant that their family previously owned. Out of this, he has a deep love for the food, wine, beer, spirits… and all things that taste good and bring people together.

Skip to content